Successfully banning high-volume hydraulic fracturing (fracking) in New York State in 2014 helped to accelerate the transition to clean energy alternatives.
Key Findings
Solar Tompkins’ promotion of solar energy led to a significant increase in residential solar installations statewide.
HeatSmart focused on reducing fossil fuel dependency for home heating, encouraging adoption of energy-efficient solutions like heat pumps.
Support from New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) allowed HeatSmart to expand statewide, preparing more homes and businesses for a fossil-free future.
Grassroots efforts and community engagement played a vital role in the successful adoption of clean energy practices in New York.
The Rise of Clean Energy in New York: From Fracking Threat to Solar Tompkins Success
Around 2010, when the threat of high-volume hydraulic fracturing, or “fracking,” was looming as a possibility for the Southern Tier of New York State, environmental activists across the region kicked into high gear. Community education and information meetings, research and legal investigations, spatial analysis and listening tours, legal and environmental advisors, creative protests, and late-night meetings with elected officials—all this, and more, led in late 2014 to the successful banning of high-volume hydraulic hydrofracking in New York State.
While the ban, alone, was a great accomplishment, tens of thousands of people across the state were also galvanized in their commitment to clean energy as a result. We knew what we didn’t want: fossil fuel dependence with its concomitant threats to our climate, air, and water. But we also had our sights on the future: what do we want our energy future to look like, and how can we say YES to that?
For starters, more solar installations, and heat pump alternatives to conventional furnaces.
In 2013 and 2014, a program called Solar Tompkins focused on the Towns of Caroline, Danby, and Dryden in Tompkins County. The goal of the program was to provide information and education about how solar energy was a viable source of electricity in Central New York, an area that many people associate with cold and dreary weather. Solar Tompkins organizers worked to identify vendors who might provide better deals on equipment and installation of solar panels if the purchases were made collectively, in bulk. Solar Tompkins was in a position to be the compiler of these orders. In the first year, 110 households joined the program. When the program expanded to all of Tompkins County in the second year, that number more than tripled.
Solar Tompkins, with the buy-in from early-adopters, provided convincing neighbor-to-neighbor proof that, indeed, solar could now be a very viable option for electricity generation in upstate New York. Mission accomplished, and the ball was rolling.
Across New York State, in fact, many communities have embraced solar power in residential settings. This animation shows the increase in solar installations between 2000 and 2021. Statewide, residential installations shot up from 61 MW at the start of 2013 to nearly 160 MW at the close of 2014.
HeatSmart: Empowering New York’s Clean Energy Transition
In 2015, organizers turned their attention to home heating, looking at ways to promote alternatives to oil and gas-burning furnaces. Home heating is a necessity in New York State about six months of the year, and accounts for over 70% of the energy use in the average home. New Yorkers have been heavily dependent on fossil fuels to provide that heat to their homes and commercial buildings. HeatSmart, a grassroots organization initially funded by grants from the Park Foundation and dedicated to creating a clear and confident path forward for early adopters, was founded in 2015.
HeatSmart’s innovative approach included education, vetting installers, decreasing costs when possible, providing home tours of existing home installations, and encouraging residents to approach their heating needs comprehensively by first making buildings more energy efficient through insulation and air-sealing and then heating and cooling them with heat pumps. Heat pumps are up to three times more efficient than typical gas furnaces. Many geothermal systems, in fact, operate at 400% efficiency. Heat pumps do, however, require a greater up-front investment to purchase and install.
What Are Heat Pumps?
Visit energy.gov to learn more about ground-source and air-source heat pumps, and how they work.
HeatSmart provided participants with guidance and confidence to take a step forward towards clean energy. The program also worked closely with both New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) and the power utility New York State Electric and Gas (NYSEG) to make installation incentives available. In addition, grant funds provided subsidies for lower- and middle-income installations through the EmPower program. In 2017, the Town of Lansing, New York, implemented a moratorium on gas hook-ups for new construction. As a result, NYSERDA provided additional funding to support intensive efforts by HeatSmart Tompkins in the Town of Lansing.
HeatSmart participants cited a concern about their carbon footprint and climate change as the strongest motivation to connect with the program, with cost savings as a close second reason.
In 2017, three Tompkins County households participated in rebate programs for installing air-source heat pumps. When the program completed in 2022, 1203 Tompkins County households had participated in total. In 2017, no Chemung County households participated in rebate programs for installing air-source heat pumps. When the program was completed in 2022, 87 Chemung County households had participated in the program.
In 2017, four Tompkins County households participated in rebate programs for installing ground-source heat pumps. When the program completed in 2022, 238 Tompkins County households had participated in total. In 2017, one Chemung County household participated in rebate programs for installing ground-source heat pumps. When the program was completed in 2022, 46 Chemung County households had participated in the program.
HeatSmart Expands Statewide
HeatSmart Tompkins, though conceived and implemented by local residents and private grants, attracted early interest from NYSERDA and shared information on all its activities and accomplishments. By 2017, NYSERDA initiated its Clean Heating and Cooling Communities program and encouraged local groups throughout the state to engage in similar activities. A majority of these independent efforts chose to name themselves as additional HeatSmart efforts.
By 2019, HeatSmart, which had initially focused only on Tompkins County, essentially became a statewide program, creating jobs, and readying even more homes and businesses for a fossil-free future. Like Solar Tompkins, the peer-to-peer and neighbor-to-neighbor promotion and education helped to increase adoption of these new technologies. The high level of involvement of the team, enthusiasm for a fossil-free future for our communities, and the independence of the group that allowed personal interaction all helped to keep momentum moving ahead for this pioneering model for adoption of clean energy in a community.
What’s Next for HeatSmart?
HeatSmart ran as an independent program from 2017 to 2022. Early in 2023, HeatSmart Tompkins decided that, as with its original solar programs, its mission of community ground-breaking was accomplished. NYSERDA rechanneled its efforts and funding into newly created New York State Clean Energy Hubs, which operate as twelve regional consortiums, providing career opportunities, education on reducing energy costs, advice on home improvements, and access to rebates for installation.
Installing a Heat Pump
Both authors of this article enjoy heating and cooling through heat exchange systems in their homes. Former Heatsmart Program Director Jonathan Comstock uses air source heat pumps, and Karen Edelstein uses a groundsource system.
The Department of Energy reports that homeowners can save $1,000 per year by switching to an air-source heat pump. This means that heat pumps can eventually pay for themselves, depending on typical energy consumption. Homeowners can also reduce the cost of heat pump installation with tax credits. Energy Star supplies a 30% (or $2,000 maximum) tax credit for air-source heat pumps. We suggest researching all of Energy Star’s tax credits to learn other ways to save.
Read the testimonials below for more information about the benefits of heat pumps for home heating and cooling, and explore the additional resources to find out how you can make the switch to a safer, more efficient heat exchange system.
We really like that we’ve been able to remove all the combustion products from our home so that we don’t have to worry about gas leaks or carbon monoxide.
I consider all my clean energy investments part of my financial security during retirement. By greatly shrinking my utility costs, I will be more economically resilient even in the face of our uncertain times.
Particularly with the summers getting warmer than they used to be, we really enjoy having the air conditioning as well as the heating. It’s been easy to use.
Where to Learn More
Topics in This Article:
Join the Conversation
Stay Informed
FracTracker Newsletter
Support Our Work
FracTracker Alliance helps communicate the risks of oil and gas and petrochemical development to advance just energy alternatives that protect public health, natural resources, and the climate.
By contributing to FracTracker, you are helping to make tangible changes, such as decreasing the number of oil and gas wells in the US, protecting the public from toxic and radioactive chemicals, and stopping petrochemical expansion into vulnerable communities.
Your donations help fund the sourcing and analysis of new data so that we can keep you informed and continually update our resources.
Please donate to FracTracker today as a way to advocate for clean water, clean air, and healthy communities.
What You Should Read Next

Pipeline Incidents Are a Daily Occurrence

Environmental Justice Analysis of Oil Extraction in Los Angeles Communities

How Increased Protective Buffer Zones Could Help Protect 3.6 million Pennsylvanians

Regulatory Gaps and Resistance: The Battle Over Fracking in Southern Illinois

Can California Energy Policy Move Past its Contradictions?

Data Gaps: A Critical Examination of Oil and Gas Well Incidents in Ohio

Indigenous Communities’ Fight Against CO2 Pipelines in the Great Plains

Pennsylvania Oil and Gas Industry Trends: Drilled Wells, Violations, Production, and Waste

A Closer Look at Risks of the Appalachian Hydrogen Hub

Falcon Pipeline Criminal Charges Explained

The Importance of Surveying Rural Landowners in North Dakota on Fracking

Exploring the Fallout of Precision Scheduled Rail: A Rail Worker’s Perspective on Precision Scheduled Rail

Not-So-Radical Transparency: An Ineffective and Unnecessary Partnership Between Pennsylvania Governor Shapiro and the Gas Company CNX

California Must Improve Management of Idle Wells

Holes in FracFocus

Mapping PFAS Chemicals Used in Fracking Operations in West Virginia

Chevron’s $2.3 Billion Asset Adjustment Raises Questions Amidst Regulatory Changes in California

Stop Toxic Threat: A Heavy Industrial Zoning Battle

East Palestine Warning: The Growing Threat From Hazardous Waste Storage

Index of Oil and Gas Operator Health in California Shows Risks to State Economy and Taxpayers

Calling for Change: Life on the Fracking Frontlines

On the Wrong Track: Risks to Residents of the Upper Ohio River Valley From Railroad Incidents

Digital Atlas: Exploring Nature and Industry in the Raccoon Creek Watershed

Why Do Houses Keep Exploding in One Pennsylvania Suburb?

FracTracker Alliance Releases Statement Opposing Governor Shapiro’s Agreement With CNX

Oil and Gas Activity Within California Public Health Protection Zones

Assessment of Oil and Gas Well Ownership Transfers in California

Evaluation of the Capacity for Water Recycling for Colorado Oil and Gas Extraction Operations

Evidence Shows Oil and Gas Companies Use PFAS in New Mexico Wells

CalGEM Permit Review Q1 2023: Well Rework Permits Increase by 76% in California

2022 Pipeline Incidents Update: Is Pipeline Safety Achievable?

Testimony On EPA’s Proposed Methane Pollution Standards for the Oil and Gas Industry

Assessment of Rework Permits on Oil Production from Operational Wells Within the 3,200-Foot Public Health Protection Zone

CalGEM Permit Review Q4 2022: Oil Permit Approvals Show Steep Rise Within Protective Buffer Zones

A Contentious Landscape of Pipeline Build-outs in the Eastern US

Major Gas Leak Reveals Risks of Aging Gas Storage Wells in Pennsylvania

Coursing Through Gasland: A Digital Atlas Exploring Natural Gas Development in the Towanda Creek Watershed

Falcon Pipeline Online, Begins Operations Following Violations of Clean Streams Law

Synopsis: Risks to the Greater Columbus Water Supply from Oil and Gas Production

Desalination: The Chemical Industry’s Demand for Water in Texas

Take Action in Support of No New Leases

Carbon Capture and Storage: Developments in the Law of Pore Space in North Dakota

Carbon Capture and Storage: Industry Connections and Community Impacts

Carbon Capture and Storage: Fact or Fiction?

Pipeline Right-of-Ways: Making the Connection between Forest Fragmentation and the Spread of Lyme Disease in Southwestern Pennsylvania

FracTracker Finds Widespread Hydrocarbon Emissions from Active & Idle Oil and Gas Wells and Infrastructure in California

California Regulators Approve More Oil Well Permits Amid a Crisis of Leaking Oil Wells that Should be Plugged

An Insider Take on the Appalachian Hydrogen & CCUS Conference

Does Hydrogen Have a Role in our Energy Future?

Oil and Gas Brine in Ohio

PA Environment Digest Blog: Conventional Oil & Gas Drillers Dispose Of Drill Cuttings By ‘Dusting’

Real Talk on Pipelines

2021 Production from Pennsylvania’s Oil and Gas Wells

Mapping Energy Systems Impacted by the Russia-Ukraine War

Dimock residents working to protect water from a new threat: fracking waste

Implications of a 3,200-foot Setback in California

New Trends in Drilling Permit Approvals Take Shape in CA

Oil and Gas Drilling in California Legislative Districts

New Report: Fracking with “Forever Chemicals” in Colorado

Introducing: FracTracker’s comprehensive new Pennsylvania map!

New Letter from Federal Regulators Regarding how the Falcon has Been Investigated

US Army Corps Muskingum Watershed Plan ignores local concerns of oil and gas effects

Oil and gas companies use a lot of water to extract oil in drought-stricken California

Southeastern Texas Petrochemical Industry Needs 318 Billion Gallons of Water, but the US EPA Says Not So Fast

Chickahominy Pipeline project tries to exploit an apparent regulatory loophole

Map Update on Criminal Charges Facing Mariner East 2 Pipeline

It’s Time to Stop Urban Oil Drilling in Los Angeles

Infrastructure Networks in Texas

California Prisons are Within 2,500’ of Oil and Gas Extraction

New power plant proposal called senseless and wasteful by climate groups

Ongoing Safety Concerns over Shell’s Falcon Pipeline

New Neighborhood Drilling Permits Issued While California Fails to Act on Public Health Rules

The world is watching as bitcoin battle brews in the US


California Oil & Gas Drilling Permits Drop in Response to Decreased Permit Applications to CalGEM

California Denies Well Stimulation Permits

Mapping PFAS “Forever Chemicals” in Oil & Gas Operations

Updated National Energy and Petrochemical Map

Ohio, West Virginia, Pennsylvania Fracking Story Map

Ohio & Fracking Waste: The Case for Better Waste Management

Pennsylvania Conventional Well Map Update

Impacts of 2020 Colonial Pipeline Rupture Continue to Grow

Gas Storage Plan vs. Indigenous Rights in Nova Scotia

Mapping Gathering Lines in Bradford County, Pennsylvania

Trends in fracking waste coming to New York State from Pennsylvania

2021 Pipeline Incidents Update: Safety Record Not Improving

New York State Oil & Gas Well Drilling: Patterns Over Time

Risky Byhalia Connection Pipeline Threatens Tennessee & Mississippi Health, Water Supply

Shell’s Falcon Pipeline Under Investigation for Serious Public Safety Threats

Kern County’s Drafted EIR Will Increase the Burden for Frontline Communities

Pennsylvania’s Waste Disposal Wells – A Tale of Two Datasets

California Oil & Gas Setbacks Recommendations Memo

Oil and Gas Wells on California State Lands

Industrial Impacts in Michigan: A Photo Essay & Story Map

People and Production: Reducing Risk in California Extraction

Documenting emissions from new oil and gas wells in California


FracTracker in the Field: Building a Live Virtual Map


Mapping Gathering Lines in Ohio and West Virginia

The North Dakota Shale Viewer Reimagined: Mapping the Water and Waste Impact

Falcon Pipeline Construction Releases over 250,000 Gallons of Drilling Fluid in Pennsylvania and Ohio

Systematic Racism in Kern County Oil and Gas Permitting Ordinance

Fracking Water Use in Pennsylvania Increases Dramatically

New Yorkers mount resistance against North Brooklyn Pipeline

California, Back in Frack

California Setback Analyses Summary

Air Pollution from Pennsylvania Shale Gas Compressor Stations – REPORT

New York State Oil & Gas Wells – 2020 Update

National Energy and Petrochemical Map

Governor Newsom Must Do More to Address the Cause of Oil Spill Surface Expressions

Oil & Gas Well Permits Issued By Newsom Administration Rival Those Issued Under Gov. Jerry Brown

Pipelines Continue to Catch Fire and Explode

The Hidden Inefficiencies and Environmental Costs of Fracking in Ohio

Fracking in Pennsylvania: Not Worth It

Fracking Threatens Ohio’s Captina Creek Watershed


How State Regulations Hold Us back and What Other Countries are doing about Fracking

New Method for Locating Abandoned Oil and Gas Wells is Tested in New York State


Abandoned Wells in Pennsylvania: We’re Not Doing Enough


The Underlying Politics and Unconventional Well Fundamentals of an Appalachian Storage Hub

Permitting New Oil and Gas Wells Under the Newsom Administration

Mapping the Petrochemical Build-Out Along the Ohio River

Impact of a 2,500′ Oil and Gas Well Setback in California

Production and Location Trends in PA: A Moving Target

The Falcon Public Monitoring Project

Release: The 2019 You Are Here map launches, showing New York’s hurdles to climate leadership

Idle Wells are a Major Risk

Literally Millions of Failing, Abandoned Wells

Wicked Witch of the Waste

The Growing Web of Oil and Gas Pipelines

Unnatural Disasters

Getting Rid of All of that Waste – Increasing Use of Oil and Gas Injection Wells in Pennsylvania

A Disturbing Tale of Diminishing Returns in Ohio

Pennsylvania Drilling Trends in 2018
216 Franklin St, Suite 400, Johnstown, PA 15901
Phone: +1 (717) 303-0403 | info@fractracker.org
FracTracker Alliance is a 501(c)3 non-profit: Tax identification number: 80-0844297